Interest

8th January 2026 · History & Philosophy of Physics; Physics Education · 7 entries

History & Philosophy of Physics

1. Discrete symmetries in classical and quantum oscillators[2601.01960]
Abstract

We consider the nature of the wave function using the example of a harmonic oscillator. We show that the eigenfunctions $\psi_n{=}z^n$ of the quantum Hamiltonian in the complex Bargmann-Fock-Segal representation with $z\in\mathbb C$ are the coordinates of a classical oscillator with energy $E_n=\hbar\omega n$, $n=0,1,2,...\,$. They are defined on conical spaces ${\mathbb C}/{\mathbb Z}_n$ with cone angles $2\pi/n$, which are embedded as subspaces in the phase space $\mathbb C$ of the classical oscillator. Here ${\mathbb Z}_n$ is the finite cyclic group of rotations of the space $\mathbb C$ by an angle $2\pi/n$. The superposition $\psi =\sum_n c_n\psi_n$ of the eigenfunctions $\psi_n$ arises only with incomplete knowledge of the initial data for solving the Schrödinger equation, when the conditions of invariance with respect to the discrete groups ${\mathbb Z}_n$ are not imposed and the general solution takes into account all possible initial data parametrized by the numbers $n\in\mathbb N$.

2. Local Scale Invariance in Quantum Theory: A Non-Hermitian Pilot-Wave Formulation[2601.03567]
Abstract

We show that Weyl's abandoned idea of local scale invariance has a natural realization at the quantum level in pilot-wave (deBroglie-Bohm) theory. We obtain the Weyl covariant derivative by complexifying the electromagnetic gauge coupling parameter. The resultant non-hermiticity has a natural interpretation in terms of local scale invariance of the quantum state in pilot-wave theory. The conserved current density is modified from $|\psi|^2$ to the local scale invariant, trajectory-dependent ratio $|\psi|^2/ \mathbf{1}^2[\mathcal{C}]$, where $\mathbf 1[\mathcal C]$ is a scale factor that depends on the pilot-wave trajectory $\mathcal C$ in configuration space. Our approach is general, and we implement it for the Schrödinger, Pauli, and Dirac equations coupled to an external electromagnetic field. We also implement it in quantum field theory for the case of a quantized axion field interacting with a quantized electromagnetic field. We discuss the equilibrium probability density and show that the corresponding trajectories are unique.

3. Towards a Generalized Theory of Observers[2504.16225]
Abstract

We propose a formal framework for understanding and unifying the concept of observers across physics, computer science, philosophy, and related fields. Building on cybernetic feedback models, we introduce an operational definition of minimal observers, explore their role in shaping foundational concepts, and identify what remains unspecified in their absence. Drawing upon insights from quantum gravity, digital physics, second-order cybernetics, and recent ruliological and pregeometric approaches, we argue that observers serve as indispensable reference points for measurement, reference frames, and the emergence of meaning. We show how this formalism sheds new light on debates related to consciousness, quantum measurement, and computational boundaries; by way of theorems on observer equivalences and complexity measures. This perspective opens new avenues for investigating how complexity and structure arise in both natural and artificial systems.

Physics Education

4. Feedback Indices to Evaluate LLM Responses to Rebuttals for Multiple Choice Type Questions[2601.03285]
Abstract

We present a systematic framework of indices designed to characterize Large Language Model (LLM) responses when challenged with rebuttals during a chat. Assessing how LLMs respond to user dissent is crucial for understanding their reliability and behavior patterns, yet the complexity of human-LLM interactions makes systematic evaluation challenging. Our approach employs a fictitious-response rebuttal method that quantifies LLM behavior when presented with multiple-choice questions followed by deliberate challenges to their fictitious previous response. The indices are specifically designed to detect and measure what could be characterized as sycophantic behavior (excessive agreement with user challenges) or stubborn responses (rigid adherence to the fictitious response in the chat history) from LLMs. These metrics allow investigation of the relationships between sycophancy, stubbornness, and the model's actual mastery of the subject matter. We demonstrate the utility of these indices using two physics problems as test scenarios with various OpenAI models. The framework is intentionally generalizable to any multiple-choice format question, including on topics without universally accepted correct answers. Our results reveal measurable differences across OpenAI model generations, with trends indicating that newer models and those employing greater "Reasoning Effort" exhibit reduced sycophantic behavior. The FR pairing method combined with our proposed indices provides a practical, adaptable toolkit for systematically comparing LLM dialogue behaviors across different models and contexts.

5. Visualizing Mathieu-Type Dynamics in a Tabletop Magnetic Trap: A Coil-Driven Parametric Oscillator[2601.03409]
Abstract

We present a tabletop demonstration of dynamic stabilization and ponderomotive-like trapping using a pair of sinusoidally-driven anti-Helmholtz coils and a suspended permanent magnet. The oscillating field produces a rapid micromotion superimposed on a slower secular oscillation, with micromotion amplitude increasing with displacement and peaking near the turning points. This behavior reveals a ponderomotive-like mechanism: a spatial gradient of micromotion amplitude that drives slow secular motion. The time-averaged effect provides a time-averaged harmonic (ponderomotive) restoring force that confines the magnet between the coils. Driving at 12-18 Hz places the system in a small-q regime where the two time scales are clearly separated and directly visible to the eye. Video tracking (included with this article) quantifies the motion and reveals a stability edge as the drive frequency is lowered (near 6-7 Hz in our apparatus). From trajectories in the 12-18 Hz range, we extract an effective Mathieu parameter q   0.16 from the measured timescale separation of the secular versus drive frequencies. The apparatus uses inexpensive, readily available parts, and we provide a concise materials list, analysis code, field-gradient calibration data, and demonstration videos.

6. A Minimal Thermo-Fluid Model for Pressure-Driven Extraction in a Moka Pot[2601.03663]
Abstract

The moka pot provides a familiar example of a thermally driven flow system in which heating, vapor pressure generation, and fluid extraction are strongly coupled. We present a minimal, dimensionless dynamical model describing the evolution of temperature, pressure, and extracted volume during moka pot brewing. The model consists of a small set of coupled ordinary differential equations incorporating constant heating, heat loss, vapor pressure buildup, and pressure-driven flow through the coffee bed. The heating stage of the model is quantitatively compared with published experimental temperature time data, allowing the characteristic thermal timescale to be fixed independently. Using the experimentally constrained temperature evolution as input, the model predicts the pressure rise and identifies the onset of extraction without additional fitting parameters. Despite its simplicity, the model exhibits several qualitatively distinct extraction regimes, including delayed onset of flow, smooth extraction, and rapid extraction driven by nonlinear feedback between temperature and pressure. These regimes are governed by a small number of dimensionless parameters with clear physical interpretation. Rather than providing detailed quantitative predictions for specific devices, the model is intended as a transparent pedagogical framework for illustrating how physicists construct, simplify, and test coupled thermo-fluid models using experimentally accessible data in an everyday physical system in an everyday physical context.

7. Dissecting Physics Reasoning in Small Language Models: A Multi-Dimensional Analysis from an Educational Perspective[2505.20707]
Abstract

Small Language Models (SLMs) offer privacy and efficiency for educational deployment, yet their utility depends on reliable multistep reasoning. Existing benchmarks often prioritize final answer accuracy, obscuring 'right answer, wrong procedure' failures that can reinforce student misconceptions. This work investigates SLM physics reasoning reliability, stage wise failure modes, and robustness under paired contextual variants. We introduce Physbench, comprising of 3,162 high school and AP level physics questions derived from OpenStax in a structured reference solution format with Bloom's Taxonomy annotations, plus 2,700 paired culturally contextualized variants. Using P-REFS, a stage wise evaluation rubric, we assess 10 SLMs across 58,000 responses. Results reveal substantial reliability gap: among final answer correct solutions, 75 to 98% contain at least one reasoning error. Failure modes shift with model capability; weaker models fail primarily at interpretation or modeling while stronger models often fail during execution. Paired contextual variations have minimal impact on top models but degrade the performance of mid-tier models. These findings demonstrate that safe educational AI requires evaluation paradigms that prioritize reasoning fidelity over final-answer correctness.